Original size 832x1216

SOUND IN THE GNOSEOLOGICAL SYSTEM OF ANCIENT INDIAN VEDIC TRADITION

PROTECT STATUS: not protected
Longread translated automatically

This work is dedicated to analyzing one of the fundamental methods of true cognition in ancient Indian philosophy, connected to auditory perception (sabda), which is examined through the lens of the unique features of the ancient Indian epistemological system—specifically, its rooting in ontological concepts and transcendent modes of knowledge.

The epistemological system of ancient Indian philosophy is as enigmatic as it is complex to comprehend within the framework of Western European thought’s concepts and categories. Nevertheless, it remains an alluring subject for a large number of scholars.

The mode of knowing itself constituted a specific, hierarchically structured path comprising several stages. The true method of knowing, termed pramana (measure, standard, proof) or prama (foundation, true, valid knowledge), encompasses several types of cognitive activity.

post

1) Pratyaksha (Sanskrit: pratyaksa — that which is before the eyes, visible, perceived, immediate) — direct, sensory perception arising from the contact of the senses and their objects; 2) Anumana (Sanskrit: anumana — conclusion, inference, argument) — rational knowledge derived through reasoning; 3) Shabda (Sanskrit: sabda — sound, word, name, utterance, speech) — perception derived from authoritative sacred texts, or supra-sensory hearing; 4) Arsha (Sanskrit: — established, defined by sages, ancient) — revelation given by the first Rishis; 5) Upamana (Sanskrit: upamana — resemblance, comparison, likeness, that with which something is compared) — recognition by similarity; 6) Arthapatti — presumption, supposition; 7) Abhava (Sanskrit: abhava — absence, deficiency, non-existence) — method of knowledge through the negation of existence; 8) Sambhava (Sanskrit: sambhava — sacred) — inclusion into existence; 9) Cheshta — active knowledge, action; 10) Akhyā — knowledge based on tradition.

Indian pramanas neither contradict nor stand in opposition to European methods of knowing; they are simply more complex due to their hierarchical structure, where each level of any pramana corresponds to a specific level of the philosopher-adherent’s consciousness.

Let us turn directly to the pramana related to auditory perception, which is called Shabda. The Sanskrit word sabda literally means «based on sound or words; verbal, oral; sonic; based on the sacred word.» This pramana is practiced by all ancient Indian religious and philosophical schools and is part of the core pramanas, alongside pratyaksha and anumana. The Vedanta school recognizes Shabda as the most important of all pramanas.

In the Vedic tradition, four levels of sound and speech (Chatvarivaka) are distinguished:

«Speech is measured in four quarters. The Brahmins, who are wise, know them. They keep three (quarters) secretly and do not let them be used. People speak in the fourth (quarter).»

post

The first level of sound and speech, parā-vāk, is the highest transcendental sound—it can be understood as the primary vibration (spanda) of the Original Source, or a pre-sound that is imperceptible to the senses.

The second level, paśyanti-vāk, is visible speech—manifest sound—that only expresses a certain principle without conveying specifics of the visible world.

The third level, madhyamā-vāk, is «intermediate speech.» It already contains the idea or eidos of a thing and is connected to it, yet it remains on its own internal plane.

And the final, fourth level, vācikarī-vāk, is clear, spoken language. All human speech and music exist at this level.

How is pramana shabda realized if speech is perceived only at the final, fourth manifested level—the vaikhari-vāk?

Thus, the method of perceiving truth through the fourth level of manifest sound, or Vaikhari-vāk, corresponds to accepting knowledge from an authoritative source. In the Eastern tradition, knowledge was primarily transmitted orally from teacher to student, although it could also be documented in texts.

The next level—Madhyama Vāk, or the middle speech—becomes a kind of auditory pratyāhāra—a withdrawal from all external sounds and an inward listening. Literally, the word Madhyama translates to «that which has no beginning and no end»; it refers to the center, the inner core, which can only possess a depth coordinate. Only from the depth of this inner center is the path to one’s highest beginning—Buddhi, or the Soul—possible.

At a certain stage of deepening, the adept begins to hear the voice of their Buddha as a vibration or resonance with themselves. At this stage, knowledge is achieved through questioning their higher principle or through a call and response. The philosophic adept begins to see the truth through the eyes of their Buddha—this is the next level of speech: paśyanti-vāk, or visible sound.

And in the final stage, the subject of knowledge fully identifies with its Higher Self, or its small atman, which is a tiny particle of the Great Creator, and comes to know the laws of unified life, as well as its true reality, or its para-vak. In the religious tradition of the Vedas, it is believed that only great Teachers reached such a height—among whom were the first Rishis, to whom the Vedas were directly revealed—meaning these were the subjects capable of ascending to the perception level of para-vak, where the laws and principles of unified life exist in an unverbalized form.

To know the truth is to ascend to the original highest sound—the sound beyond the coarse external sounds perceived by the senses; it is to grasp the subtle, inaudible sound perceived by the soul (buddhi) and the small human spirit (atman). Ultimately, shabda is not merely a path to knowing the truth, but the spiritual path itself of an ancient Indian philosopher-adept. Consequently, the totality of the soundscape of the ancient Indian religious-philosophical tradition is revealed to us, in which sound functions as both a cognizable reality and the subject’s most crucial epistemological tool.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

  1. Voevodina L. N. Mythological Representations and the Separation of the Sacred Sphere in Archaic Culture // Bulletin of Moscow State University of Culture and Arts. 2012. No. 6 (50).
  2. Donets A. M. Theory of True Knowledge in Madhyamika-Prasangika Philosophy. Ulan-Ude: BNTS RA Publishing House, 2006.
  3. Yelizarenkova T. Ya. Language and Style of Vedic Rishis: [Ancient Indian Monument «Rigveda»]. Moscow: Nauka: Eastern Literature Publishing House, 1993. 315 p.
  4. Kochergina V. A. Sanskrit-Russian Dictionary. Moscow: Russian Language, 1987.
  5. Radhakrishnan S. Indian Philosophy. Moscow: Foreign Literature, 1957. Vol. 2.
  6. Shokhin V. K. Schools of Indian Philosophy: The Period of Formation 4th Century BCE — 2nd Century CE: [Monograph]. Moscow: Eastern Literature, 2004.
  7. Sri Swami Sivananda Sarasvati. Kundalini Yoga / Translated from English and Edited by A. Ochapovsky [Electronic Resource] // A. Ochapovsky Yoga Library. Ufa. 2002.
SOUND IN THE GNOSEOLOGICAL SYSTEM OF ANCIENT INDIAN VEDIC TRADITION
Project created at 20.02.2025
We use cookies to improve the operation of the website and to enhance its usability. More detailed information on the use of cookies can be fo...
Show more